zstone at gmail.com
Thu Oct 30 01:33:16 EDT 2008
Isn't the new email system mostly irrelevant? Most of the students I
know use Gmail and ignore Harvard's email system entirely; at most,
they forward messages from there to Gmail. There's no way that Harvard
can provide a better user experience than Gmail does, so this whole
issue barely matters.
Just my impression as a resident tutor,
On Thu, Oct 30, 2008 at 1:10 AM, Bruno Afonso <bafonso at gmail.com> wrote:
> Hey guys,
> I've met with some of the persons from FAS IT involved in this switch.
> This was regarding changing gsas student's to the new system.
> Some thoughts on this:
> - harvard would never be able to give to their students 5gig emails
> anytime in the near future. outsourcing would be the only way.
> - I agree that the name schema is not perfect. But, there's no perfect
> one. I'm not defending this particular one, i'm just trying to make
> you guys think in reasonable terms. Arbitrary names have several
> issues actually, first and foremost people getting important and
> confidential information sent to others because someone now is
> re-using the email. I know several MIT'ers that have had this happen
> to them.
> The idea is to avoid email re-usage altogether as far as I know. They
> don't want that. Arbitrary names would involve that. Now, you will
> have several options. I think it also contemplates first letter and
> last name. The user can change between several options at registration
> I think.
> Gmail has several legal problems and that's a gmail option killer as
> far as I know. Microsoft live was also contemplated at a point in
> time. I have not personally used the new system as it will only be a
> pilot system for grad students in some months I believe.
> People that want to use web page storage quirk will have to use the
> older system probably with the newly centralized auth system that is
> being made. Also, it will not be as publicized. Honestly, think of the
> bigger picture. how many students even use anything else besides
> webmail? very very few. Those can get some features they want if they
> ask for it.
> I'm glad harvard will be giving grad students decent inbox size email
> w/ imap access instead of the current system. for 95% of the grad
> students (and I bet undergrad) it won't make any difference.
> At any rate, if you feel that you need to improve the system, now is
> the time to speak to FAS IT as they're still on pilot trials, etc.
> Bruno Afonso
> http://brunoafonso.com (personal, mostly portuguese)
> http://openwetware.org/wiki/User:BrunoAfonso (Professional, english)
> hcs-discuss mailing list
> hcs-discuss at lists.hcs.harvard.edu
More information about the hcs-discuss